# Model shows a lifeless Earth could have stayed habitable for billions of years

- URL: https://syn.by/en/technology/science/model-lifeless-earth-habitable/
- Published: 2026-11-17T18:00:17+00:00
- Updated: 2026-11-18T05:10:02+00:00
- Section: Science
- Language: en
- RU edition: https://syn.by/ru/tekhnologii/nauka/zemlya-zhizn-milliard-god.md
- BE edition: https://syn.by/technalohii/navuka/madel-ziamlia-zhyccio.md

> In the lifeless model, the only notable difference at the surface is the absence of oxygen in the atmosphere. The authors acknowledge the limitations and simplifications of their model.

![](https://syn.by/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/illustration-7560-1024x585.webp)

An international team of scientists has modelled what Earth would look like if life had never appeared on it, and concluded that the planet could have remained habitable for more than 4.5 billion years. The study was carried out by a group led by astrobiologist Samantha Gilbert-Janizek of the University of Washington. As ScienceAlert reports, it has been published in The Planetary Science Journal.

The scientists built a model of Earth without a biosphere but with its other physical components: core, mantle, crust, atmosphere, oceans and the flow of solar radiation. They modelled 19 key characteristics of the planet, among them heat flow, the chemical composition of the oceans and surface temperature.

The virtual Earth was followed over five billion years: from the formation of the planet to a point roughly 500 million years in the future.

The absence of life did not significantly affect the planet's surface, with one exception: there is no oxygen in the atmosphere, because there is no photosynthesis. The water level in the model was comparable to the present one.

The researchers wrote: "We show that on an Earth-like planet, habitable surface temperatures can be maintained over 4.5 billion years of evolution (and more) solely through abiotic processes, without any biological mechanisms of climate regulation. The carbonate-silicate cycle, driven by the interaction of silicate weathering, volcanic degassing and chemical processes in the ocean, creates a stable negative feedback. It keeps the concentration of atmospheric CO2 and the surface temperature within limits suitable for life, even though over 4.5 billion years the Sun's luminosity has increased by about 30%."

The results indicate that the presence of life is not necessary for a rocky planet to remain habitable.

According to the Gaia hypothesis, life interacts with the planet's physical environment in a way that helps maintain conditions suitable for life. In Science Alert's assessment, the simulation offers a new perspective on the ideas underlying this hypothesis.

The authors themselves name as the central question of the work whether life is necessary for the long-term habitability of a rocky planet. The scientists acknowledge that the model has limitations and simplifications, including assumptions about plate tectonics, atmospheric chemistry and the processes that regulate Earth's climate.

Background

### How a planet keeps its climate in check

The carbonate-silicate cycle is considered the planet's climate thermostat. Volcanoes release CO2, which dissolves in rainwater and breaks down silicate rocks; rivers carry the products to the ocean, where the carbon is bound in carbonate sediments and buried. Volcanism and subduction then return it to the air. In warm, humid conditions weathering speeds up and removes CO2; when it gets colder, the gas accumulates, so the feedback is negative and works over millions of years. The Gaia hypothesis, proposed by Lovelock in the 1970s, speaks of mutual adjustment between life and the environment. Abiotic models test the alternative, but rely on simplifications, for example about plate tectonics.
